Immigration and Customs Enforcement ended its contract with Holtville on Sept.
30, the city will not receive the revenue as in previous years but the change will
not have a significant budget impact, a city official said.
ICE, under the oversight of the
Department of Homeland Security, posted a letter by regular mail and email to
the city just before the federal government’s fiscal year began on Oct.1. It
thanked the city for its collaboration since September 2014, explained Nick
Wells city manager.
“Over the five years we received
more than $800,000 but the city avoided relying on that money for any long-term
expenses and never drew upon the revenue stream,” he explained.
The funds stemmed from operation of the Imperial Regional Detention Facility, 1572 Gateway Road, Calexico. Previously, Holtville was contracted by ICE to house detainees (undocumented immigrants) as part of a five-year contract. The city, in turn, subcontracted with private contractor, Management & Training Corporation (headquartered in Centerville, Utah) to operate the detention facility.
The city received the annual revenue stream for its administration of
the contract, explained Wells.
“It can be a complex subject to
explain,” said Wells. “The city council could have treated the IRDF
revenue separately but we never sequestered that funding into another
IRDF Annual Income
However, Wells further elaborated that
while the city never actually withdrew funding from the IRDF annual income, the
city did list the resources it provided as part of its projected budget for the
upcoming fiscal year each June. In the 2017-18 fiscal year, part of the IRDF
funding was included in budget calculations that also included purchasing a
fire engine that year.
“But the fire engine purchase was
a function separate and independent and had nothing to do with the IRDF
facility,” said Wells. “The general fund surplus that year was a
piece of the puzzle of the $162,000 IRDF revenue. Technically, we relied on
part of it to balance the books that fiscal year.”
Wells added that many account balances
owed to the city do not come due until the third and fourth quarter of the
fiscal year. And in spite of relying upon the detention facility revenue to
balance 2017-18 on paper the city ended the year with $350,000 in reserve.
Yet ICE did not provide an explanation
of why it decided to end the contract. State law requires cities receiving detention
facility resources to have a state audit of those funds to assure accounting
procedures adhere to the standard in which California deems to be proper, noted
“ICE really didn’t feel they needed to submit to the California audit,” said Wells. “They did not state it that way when they thanked us for our services and declined to renew the contract, but it was easy to decipher.”
New Fiscal Year After ICE Cut
Holtville did receive another $45,000
to carry them through the first three months of the city’s current fiscal year
but will not be budgeted for the federal government’s new fiscal year.
“We will not get any revenue for the 2020-21 fiscal year but we
still had a surplus of $17,000 for (the first quarter) of this year,” noted
“At the time the contract was signed (the city decided) that we should at least do our best to avoid the revenue being used merely as an augmentation to our operational budget,” said Wells. “Fortunately, those conservative budgeting and spending practices will make the loss uncomfortable, but survivable.”
Meanwhile, the future of some
privately run detention centers is in doubt due to a new state law.
On Oct. 11, Gov. Gavin Newsom signed
Assembly Bill 32 sponsored by Rob Bonta (D-Oakland). It prohibits the state Department
of Corrections and Rehabilitation from entering in to or renewing a contract
with a private, for-profit prison to incarcerate state prison inmates. But it
does not prohibit it from renewing a contract to house state prison inmates to
comply with a court-ordered population cap, effective after Jan. 1, 2020.
The above bill also prohibits a state
prison inmate from being incarcerated in a private, for-profit prison facility,
after Jan. 1, 2028.
Information was not immediately
available on how that might affect
private detention centers in the state housing federal inmates.